MURDER MYSTERY DINNER
MudHen Brewing Company Presents
Mayflower Murder! A Thanksgiving Murder Mystery Dinner
Monday, November 23, 2026 — Seating begins promptly at 5:30PM
$50 Tickets includes 3 – Course Prix Fixe Dinner
FIRST COURSE
Autumn Harvest Salad
Mixed greens, sliced apples, dried cranberries, candied pecans, goat cheese & apple cider vinaigrette
SECOND COURSE – Choice of One Entrée
Maple Dijon Chicken
Roasted chicken breast with maple Dijon glaze, roasted red bliss potatoes & seasonal vegetables
Smoked Brisket
BBQ-spiced smoked brisket & house BBQ sauce with roasted red bliss potatoes & seasonal vegetables
Crab-Stuffed Flounder
Lump crab-stuffed flounder with lemon caper cream sauce, roasted red bliss potatoes & seasonal vegetables
THIRD COURSE
Spiced Pumpkin Bundt Cake
Finished with cream cheese frosting
Bar – Cash bar available throughout the evening
Location: The Station House at MudHen Brewing Company
All aboard the Mayflower! A journey to a new beginning has taken a deadly turn, and this Thanksgiving, murder is on the menu!
During one of the most memorable chapters in American history, the Pilgrims set out to establish a new colony where they could practice their traditions in freedom. But little did they know, sinister forces were already stirring within their small community!
The first Thanksgiving has officially become the first Thanks-Killing!
Someone has murdered Jonathan Brewster, the leader of the community, and to make matters worse, the last of the food stores have mysteriously disappeared!
Who could be responsible? Was it a member of the local Indigenous community? A Spanish spy? A witch? Or is the killer hiding among the Pilgrims themselves?
With suspicious characters, outrageous accusations, unexpected twists, and plenty of laughs, it’s up to YOU to help uncover the truth before this wicked turkey gobbles up the Pilgrims’ last hopes!
Gather your family and friends for a Thanksgiving celebration unlike any other, filled with mystery, comedy, audience participation, and a whole lot of holiday mischief!
Will you crack the case before the final reveal, or will the killer get away with the ultimate Thanksgiving crime?
There’s no better way to kick off Thanksgiving week than with a little mystery, murder, and mayhem!
Presented by Riddlesbrood Touring Theater Company
Cancellation Policy: cancellations made with at least 48 hours’ notice will receive a refund in the form of gift cards. Cancellations made within 48 hours of the event are non-refundable.
Questions
pepa@mudhenbrew.com or call (609) 522-0159 ext. 125
Limited seating — reserve your spot early!